Change Your Image
coolbabeholls
Reviews
The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie (1969)
Terrible Scottish accents
Just watched The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie on itv and i have to say this film does not stand the test of time. It's hammy, over-egged and just a vehicle for Maggie smith to say things like "Fly forth into battle!". She won the best actress? Well I suppose it's because in those days that sort of melodramatic monologue-based performance was much more prized. But the film's main crime is the plethora of absolutely TERRIBLE Scottish accents.
Honestly this film needs an award for how many stinkers there were.
Why not set the film in Kensington or Chelsea seeing as that's where most of the cast were clearly from? Dear oh dear. Most of this cast should be thoroughly ashamed of themselves! Do you think this is the worst screen offender for bad accents or does mel Gibson in braveheart top this bill? Or there are some accents in highlander that are also pretty iffy!
Ne le dis à personne (2006)
Tell No One/Ne le dis à personne (2006) review ****
Guillaume Canet's thriller opens on one of those naturalistic dinner party scenes: all glasses clinking and laughter and dialogue just a pitch below hearing. Yet this is a misleading beginning for a film that progresses into a thoroughly surprising and superior tale of a husband's desperate search for his seemingly dead wife.
Canet executes the set-up for his tale beautifully, placing his couple stark naked, lakeside, and under the moonlight to emphasize the sheer indulgence of their love. Then with little dialogue he changes the tone from romanticism, to blinding horror as Alexandre (Francois Cluzet) hears a scream and tries in vain to save his wife Margot (Josee Croze) but is beaten over the head by her attacker.
The casting of this couple was crucial as for all its twists and turns what follows is essentially their love story; and neither Cluzet nor Croze disappoint-the latter possessing a perfect vulnerable quality (akin to Naomi Watts in 'King Kong'). However, it is to Cluzet that we owe such an absorbing tale of grief and that false friend: memory.
As we flash forward eight years he conveys sometimes only through his eyes the ever-present grief ready to resurface as soon as his wife's name is mentioned. And, this being a thriller her name is mentioned pretty quickly in the form of an email, plunging the audience into a taut whodunit/what really happened/who's hiding something tale, the answer being of course everyone. And what a terrific supporting cast we are treated with: Margot's father (Andre Dussollier) effortlessly conveys equal parts frustration and resolute duty; while one cut to Jean Rochefort's brooding and wrinkled face alerts the audience to all the pain of his past. Kristin Scott Thomas is possibly even more captivating in French and her poise and cheekbones seem to be a natural marriage with the language and Parisian backdrop. . Canet uses this midsummer Paris to his full advantage to turn up the heat on his fevered search, notably in a touching scene where Alex is racing through the sweltering streets with a giant dog.
"An innocent man" declares Alex's lawyer "does not run". (What-has she not seen 'The Fugitive'?) In any case thank goodness in this circumstance he does as these provide the most compelling scenes in which even Alex crossing a motorway becomes a thing of beauty.
What keeps us gripped though, is that we actually care about these characters and their fate-about what really happened that night (which is possibly why I put up with a slightly indulgent confession scene), and despite the fact that this thriller utterly surpassed most of the usual Hollywood offerings; I found myself craving what Tinsel Town does best: a happy ending.
**** 4/5